The Spanish national soccer player and 2023 World Cup champion, Esther González (33), is at the center of sharp criticism from the queer community. A few days after she terminated her contract with the U.S. club Gotham FC, citing a temporary withdrawal from soccer to take care of private matters in Spain, she unexpectedly announced her move to the Saudi women’s league with Al-Qadsiah.
The transfer to the Al-Qadsiah club sparked disappointment and confusion across social media and among fans. Beyond the questionable circumstances of the abrupt move, the horrific human rights situation weighs heavily: In Saudi Arabia, same-sex relationships and all sexual activity outside a heterosexual marriage are strictly illegal. For homosexuality, penalties can be draconian, including flogging up to the death penalty.
View this post on Instagram
Instagram
|
González has been openly lesbian for years and made public her relationship with her partner Estefania Cruz in 2023. In January this year, the couple welcomed a child. Observers noted that at the same time as the transfer announcement, joint photos and insights into their family life were removed from González’s Instagram profile.
Critics accuse González of hypocrisy
Critics accuse the player of hypocrisy. While Saudi Arabia is pouring massive sums into polishing its international image through sport, queer people in the country continue to live in constant fear of persecution. On her Instagram profile, users lament: “So, money is more important to you than your beliefs? Shame on you.” Another user wrote: “I know money is very important, but going there as a queer woman with a wife and a child is utterly incomprehensible. I have lost all respect for Esther.”
The FIFA decision last year sparked outrage for awarding the 2034 Men’s World Cup to Saudi Arabia (TheColu.mn reported). The German Football Association (DFB) also backed the World Cup in the host country.
Women’s football has historically been a pioneer for queer visibility and acceptance in elite sports. Critics fear that González’s move could cast doubt on that progress once again.
