Bachmann, Kline bid to stop gay marriage in nation’s capital dismissedby Andy Birkey January 15, 2010 0 comments
Reps. Michele Bachmann and John Kline joined with other Republicans in a lawsuit last week to force the District of Columbia to put same-sex marriage on the ballot. A D.C. Superior Court judge dismissed their case on Thursday.
“Today’s decision affirms the District’s effort to make our city open and inclusive,” said D.C. Mayor Adrian Fenty.
From the Minnesota Independent:
The District argued that a referendum on marriage would violate its non-discrimination laws, and a D.C. Superior Court agreed (PDF), citing among precedents a 2005 case in Minneapolis where citizens petitioned to hold a vote on medical marijuana. A Minnesota judge denied the referendum because making medical marijuana legal in Minneapolis would violate state law.
Judge Judith N. Macaluso wrote that since same-sex marriages performed outside the District were valid inside Washington, D.C., a same-sex marriage ban would “ostracize a disfavored minority in violation of District of Columbia law.”
“If enacted, the initiative would deprive only same-sex individuals of the legal status, rights, and privileges they enjoy as married persons,” wrote the judge. “Such an initiative patently ‘authorizes or would have the effect of authorizing discrimination based upon. . . actual or perceived . . . sexual orientation [or] gender identity.’”