Home News MN Senator: Bathroom bill needed because Caitlyn Jenner still likes women

MN Senator: Bathroom bill needed because Caitlyn Jenner still likes women

MN Senator: Bathroom bill needed because Caitlyn Jenner still likes women


In a lengthy interview on Thursday, Sen. Warren Limmer, Rep. Abigail Whelan, and AM 980 KKMS radio host Paul Ridgeway explained why the trio are pushing for a bill that would bar transgender youth from using school facilities that match their gender and repeal gender-inclusive policies in Minnesota schools. All three said the bill, dubbed the “Bathroom Bill,” will be a major issue in the 2016 legislative session.

Limmer, a Republican from Maple Grove, followed up on remarks by Rep. Whelan, a Republican from Anoka, and Ridgeway who criticized Caitlyn Jenner, who came out as a transgender woman in May. Limmer made a bizarre claim as to why the “Bathroom Bill” is necessary:

Limmer: You brought up Bruce Jenner going through his change surgically, and when you interview him, he’s says, ‘Yes. I’m glad I’m now a quote-unquote woman but I still have the yearnings for women!’ And so think of that type of person, a young person who wants to play on a girls team because he thinks he is more likely going to be a woman in the future and he’s now going to share a locker room.
Ridgeway: Or a shower.
Limmer: On a girls team and if Bruce Jenner still has yearnings for women… so would that young man who thinks he’s a girl in a girls’ locker room…
Ridgeway: Yeah the thing is actually, it’s not only crazy, it’s diabolical.

Earlier in the interview, the three speakers propagated myths about the transgender community. Including a statement by Whelan that somehow being transgender is contagious:

Ridgeway: Sen. Limmer, I don’t know, but transgender… the whole High School League mess, and by the way the whole transgender thing is just steamrolling around the country and the world, you know? You can already see and I don’t say this lightly, and I was talking to Dr. Marcus Bachmann on our clergy cruise yesterday in the St. Croix. Satan knows his time is short. These things are passing everywhere you know? But your thoughts Senator on transgender and the whole transgender mess.
Limmer: My advice to anyone listening is: If you are not involved in trying to define what is happening on the transgender issue, and how it’s being forced on your children and being forced on society, you will be very soon. And the reason I say that is just in Minnesota the State High School League last fall changed their rules and said that if any child — now think of this — a child who thinks that they may be a different gender than they actually were born can play… Let’s say a boy that thinks he’s a girl can play on a girls team. Now that’s in violation of all the rules, on mixing sexes of kids on teams because obviously boys are a little heavier they are a little more muscularity in it. That doesn’t change if you think you are a girl, it just means that you are now allowed to play on girls teams. If you think…
Ridgeway: What about showering because I mean right now at Harvard, a woman who was given a swimming scholarship has just said she’s a boy and she’s having sex treatment and she’s going to be swimming with the boys and showering with the boys, and folks? There’s something wrong here, am I missing it? Rep. Whelan, your thoughts.
Whelan: I worked pretty closely with the chief author of the bill in the House that would have addressed this issue, and we did actually end up passing it as an amendment onto the education omnibus bill. Now, unfortunately it was stripped out during conference committee as an amendment. The reason for me this issue is so important is, number one, a safety issue. It’s a safety issue, for young people… I actually think that Sen. [Michelle] Benson, one of our colleagues in the Senate, Benson said it very well when they were debating this. You know, you have two kids who are going to school together from kindergarten. Now, maybe they are 10 years old and one’s a boy and one’s a girl and we’ll say one of them says, ‘You know what? I no longer feel like a boy. I want to be a girl. Well, now this little girl who was with this child for you know 5 to 6 years is going to the bathroom with him and unfortunately, you know, that girl goes home and says, ‘Mom, dad, I don’t understand’ You know, ‘so and so was a boy and is now a girl, like am I still a girl or am I a boy now? You as a parent have to deal with that and it just… unfortunately it raises a lot of scary questions.

After a commercial break, Ridgeway, Limmer, and Whelan continued their conversation which included Whelan making the inaccurate statement that having gender confirmation procedures results in higher suicide rates for transgender people. Whelan’s information appears to come from the writings of Dr. Paul McHugh, an anti-LGBT activist whose career was at Johns Hopkins University. Author Mari Brighe’s “Clinging to a dangerous past: Dr Paul McHugh’s selective reading of transgender medical literature” tells the tale of how McHugh distorted research for an anti-transgender agenda.

Whelan: I know, that brings me back to the the transgender issue real quick. I just wanted to mention, you know, when we look at this issue, the long term effects for example of a transgender operation, when they do studies on it, the suicide rates for those folks increases 20 times and we’re not just talking about these individuals. This will affect taxpayers at some point. They are talking about having taxpayer funded transgender surgeries, taxpayer funded hormone suppression therapy for kids, and they don’t even know the long terms effects of that. But one of the things is if you are a young person, you might become infertile by going through some of these things. So when we are talking about, you know, what Sen. Limmer brought up earlier with the sports teams and bathrooms in schools, it really is a lot broader… We want to get to this issue so it doesn’t keep going but if we don’t it will keep going and see, you know, we need to be praying about this for sure.
Ridgeway: Well, let me just say this too. One of my atheist friend who listens laughed at me, but a pro-gay leader said this whole transgender thing is just the beginning. ‘We have a whole plan’ and everybody was ‘Oh that’s not really, the gays don’t really have a plan.’ Well, yes they do.
Whelan: Mmm hmm.
Ridgeway: And it’s far more and I tell you folks, Johns Hopkins University, which led the sex change in 1960s stopped doing it not only because the suicide rate, they realized this was a psychological problem both physical and mental, the men who became women and the women who became men, were still women and they were still men and this is crazy and I see Satan now bringing Bruce Jenner in his timing you know but it’s still a man and still a woman. God made two types of people but it’s certainly a psychological problem.

Ridgeway asked Whelan and Limmer what the top issues were going to be in the 2016 legislative session slated to begin in March:

Whelan: For me personally, it will be the transgender issue and I am very very hopeful, and I want to, again, just do a call to prayer for this issue that we can get some positive legislation passed.
Ridgeway: I want to just reiterate what Rep. Whelan just said. She asks for prayer. You know we’ve been praying as listeners. One thing God laid on my heart about 3 or 4 weeks ago, he says ‘Paul, you can motivate and you can call up prayer for your listeners to come to my throne and pray,’ so will you pray for the legislature and for Rep. Whelan and Sen. Limmer and others that are godly but that they will take on the issues and they’ll get favor at the legislature for those godly issues. Thank you. And Sen. Limmer your thoughts real quick?
Limmer: Well, I think we are only going to have a two and a half month session. It’s going to be very fast. It’s going to start March 8… Late. We are remodeling the Capitol, so we need to push that a little bit, but the three big issues that I see: that transgender issue is certainly going to be there front and center in the Senate as it is going to be in the House.

Here’s the full interview:

Previous article Gadfly to bring queer one-act horror fest to Nimbus Theatre
Next article Around the Region: Backlash begins following marriage equality ruling
Andy Birkey has written for a number of Minnesota and national publications. He founded Eleventh Avenue South which ran from 2002-2011, wrote for the Minnesota Independent from 2006-2011, the American Independent from 2010-2013. His writing has appeared in The Advocate, The Star Tribune, The Huffington Post, Salon, Cagle News Service, Twin Cities Daily Planet, TheUptake, Vita.mn and much more. His writing on LGBT issues, the religious right and social justice has won awards including Best Beat Reporting by the Online News Association, Best Series by the Minnesota chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists, and an honorable mention by the Sex-Positive Journalism awards.


  1. Sen. Warren Limmer, Rep. Abigail Whelan, and AM 980 KKMS radio host Paul Ridgeway. Here we have three Ignorant, Uneducated, and Assuming people that most likely have never talked with a Transgender Person in their lives. It shows in their assumptions of how Trans people would act in a shower situation. Three adults speaking most illogically, producing more fodder for those as Ignorant as they are. They need a TRANS 101 Study Session and they may, Just may understand US.

  2. Sen.Limmer and Ridgway sound like two dudes whose entire understanding of what happens in women’s locker rooms is informed by straight male porn. As a cis woman member of the YWCA, I can assure them that there aren’t sexy lesbian orgies happening 24/7. Rep. Whelan would know that if she ever set foot in a building whose mission statement is “eliminating racism, empowering women.”

  3. They’re confusing the women’s restroom with the men’s restroom – It’s in the Men’s room that you can find the orgies and “foot tappers” (Just ask the GOP Conservatives….they know the codes) – If these people were 1/100th as interested in what’s happening to the country as much as they are about people’s sexual organs, maybe we could get some sh!t fixed in this country –

  4. So all the male teens will live as girls so they can go into the girls showers and gawk? How on
    Earth do these people get into office?!!!

    The interviewer even claims to know what an imaginary being named Satan is thinking and has deciphered his plan to have all the trans people come out. It is so delusional! Are you crazy?!!! I feel like I’m watching a YouTube video of some young, under-educated conspiracy theorist.

    And nothing is being “forced”. These trans kids are natural and have civil rights. This is a good thing. As soon as anyone wants to have equal rights, all of a sudden, somehow, the Christians are being persecuted.

    I’m tired to trying to make sense to these people. They are just nuts!

    If you don’t believe it, then don’t have a gender change but, leave everyone else alone. It’s none of your *xxxxxxx business!

  5. I think this group of bully politicians are the ones being, as they call it, diabolical. I have zero respect for them, especially as a person raised in Minnesota: everything they are saying is ignorant, pseudo-scientific, un-christian, anti-Minnesotan, and anti-American. More than that, what they are doing is bad karma: they will get their comeuppance somewhere.

  6. By their logic schools would need to ban lesbians from restrooms too. So… they can fund bathrooms in all public buildings for straight men and women and gay men and women. Separate but equal restrooms….. ohhh…but wait… 🙂

  7. These people are living proof of reincarnation……..Michele Bachman redux. This kind of stupidity and vacuous imagery makes me mourn for this country. I would address them individually but they are all self defining idiots who have shown their true colors and are at the very nadir of . This is the same kind of *LOGIC* that was used against segregation. I am ashamed to say I am a Minnesotan and I AM a transgender woman. This fool purports to speak for Satan and his minions…..my only comment to that How often to the voices in your head speak to you? iS there a special number they can dial to get a direct line? separate but equal same concept behind black only drinking fountains and restrooms. Now perhaps they are also volunteering to be the ones to examine wether we are innies or outies.

  8. So I’m assuming then that he will also like to make it illegal for lesbians to use the women’s bathrooms?

Comments are closed.